SCARLESS SURGERY: WHAT PATIENTS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT NOTES

Medically Reviewed by Dr. Rosmy Barrios

The thought of scars and long recovery times can be daunting when considering surgery. However, with advancements in medical technology, a new type of surgery has emerged that promises to be scarless and minimally invasive. This revolutionary procedure is called Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery, or NOTES.

This article will explore what NOTES is, how it is performed, its benefits and limitations, and current and future applications.

What is NOTES?

Natural Orifice Transluminal (sometimes spelled Translumenal) Endoscopic Surgery, or NOTES, is a minimally invasive surgical technique that involves accessing visceral organs through natural orifices such as the mouth. This approach eradicates the need for unsightly external incisions, resulting in a "scarless surgery." These procedures are also called natural orifice procedures or endoluminal surgeries.

NOTES is a relatively new technique. It was first performed in 2004 by a team of surgeons in India. Since then, it has slowly gained popularity and has been successfully performed in various parts of the world.

The technique naturally progressed from early laparoscopic surgeries and tools^[1], which made incisions up to 1.5 inches long and had to access multiple sites to reach the target area. NOTES involves no external incisions.

How is NOTES Performed?

NOTES uses an endoscope, which is a thin, adjustable tube with a camera and surgical instruments attached. The endoscope is inserted through a natural orifice and guided to the target organ through a small internal incision. The camera provides a clear view of the internal organs, and the surgical instruments are used to perform the necessary procedures. Minimally invasive surgical techniques are deployed in NOTES, such as balloon dilation to widen narrow vessels.^[2]

The incisions are made on thinner tissues, such as the stomach or rectal wall. There is also minimal recovery time, as the surgery takes place in tissues that are capable of speedy regeneration due to their rapid cellular turnover (cell renewal and replenishment).

There are four main access routes for NOTES:

• Transgastric (through the mouth): This approach is common for stomach procedures, such as gastric bypass surgery and gastric banding. It also allows for better imaging of the pelvic organs rather than entry at closer points.
• Transvaginal (through the vagina): This method is best for enhancing gynecological procedures, such as hysterectomy and tubal ligation. Some reviews of NOTES procedures indicate this is the safest entry route, with the fastest recovery time and the least complication risk.
• Transrectal (through the anus): The transrectal route is an improvement on procedures of the colon, such as colon resection and polyp removal. Both transvaginal and transrectal surgeries offer better visualization of the upper abdomen than the gastric route.
• Transvesical (through the urethra): This approach involves accessing the peritoneal cavity through the urethra and bladder.^[3] A drawback of this route is the diameter of the urethra, which limits the size of the instruments that can be used and the specimens that can be retrieved. Given the anatomical proximity and route, the transvesical port is particularly advantageous for accessing the abdominal cavity, which indicates its use for various urological and non-urological procedures such as varicocelectomy, nephrectomy, cholecystectomy, biopsies, and cancer staging. Additionally, it can be used to overcome triangulation challenges in complex procedures by providing an alternative viewing angle.

The access route a surgeon uses depends on the type of surgery and the patient's anatomy.

Current Applications of NOTES

Here are some of the applications NOTES is currently used for:

• NOTES Appendectomy: Appendix removal is one of the most established NOTES procedures. Surgeons often opt for transgastric (through the stomach) or transumbilical (through the belly button) approaches, demonstrating both safety and effectiveness.^[4]
• Gallbladder Removal: NOTES gallbladder removal (cholecystectomy) is another widespread application of this minimally invasive surgery. The transvaginal^[5] or transumbilical routes are typically adopted, and research suggests that outcomes are often on par with traditional laparoscopic surgery.
• Scarless Thyroid Surgery: Small thyroid nodules or select cases of thyroid cancer may be treatable by transoral (through the mouth) NOTES^[6]. This eliminates any visible neck scarring that is typical with traditional thyroid surgery.
• Gynecological Surgeries: NOTES has a growing presence in gynecology. Procedures like hysterectomy^[7] (uterus removal), tubal ligation^[8] (sterilization), and removal of ovarian cysts may be feasible through a transvaginal NOTES approach for selected patients, offering a potentially scarless option.
• Hernia Repair: NOTES techniques can sometimes address certain types of hernias. Surgeons may choose transgastric^[9] or transvaginal routes to access and repair the hernia, minimizing the need for external incisions.
• Biopsy Procedures: NOTES is streamlining diagnostic biopsy procedures. Some biopsies of abdominal organs like the liver, pancreas, or lymph nodes can be collected through NOTES^[10], lessening the invasiveness compared to traditional methods.

Other applications include liver cyst removal, GERD surgery, and abscess drainage and removal.

Benefits of NOTES

The main benefit of NOTES is that it is minimally invasive, leading to less scarring and pain and a shorter recovery period than conventional open surgery.

Other benefits include:

• Reduced risk of infection: Since NOTES does not involve external incisions, there is a lower risk of infection.
• Shorter hospital stay: Patients who undergo NOTES procedures typically remain hospitalized for a shorter time frame than those who opt for traditional open surgery. For many procedures, NOTES can be performed on an outpatient basis, meaning the patient can leave on the same day and recover in the comfort of their home.
• Less post-operative pain: NOTES is less invasive, resulting in less post-operative pain and discomfort. According to some reports, fewer anesthetic and pain-relieving medications were required for the procedure, which also minimizes their associated risks.
• Improved cosmetic outcome: The lack of external incisions means no scarring, resulting in a better cosmetic outcome^[11].

Limitations and Challenges of NOTES

While NOTES has many benefits, it has some limitations and challenges, including:

• Limited access: The current technology used for NOTES limits its applications in many procedures. This is because the endoscope is not as functional as a surgeon's hand and cannot perform many complex procedures.
• Risk of complications: As with all surgical procedures, there are complication risks with NOTES, such as bleeding, infection (especially urinary tract infections), and organ damage. Some specific complications include subcutaneous emphysema (air trapped beneath the skin), delayed wound healing, and lower reproductive function.^[12]
• Lack of training: NOTES  is a relatively new technique. Not all surgeons have sufficient training to use the NOTES technique. This can limit the availability of NOTES for patients.
• Cost: The equipment and technology used for NOTES can be expensive, making it less accessible for some patients.

Comparing NOTES to Laparoscopic Surgery

Laparoscopic surgery, also known as keyhole surgery, is another minimally invasive surgical method that involves making slight incisions in the abdomen to access the internal organs. While NOTES and laparoscopic surgery have many similarities, there are some key differences between the two^[13].

• Incision location: The main difference between NOTES and laparoscopic surgery is the location of the incisions. NOTES involves accessing the internal organs through natural orifices, while laparoscopic surgery involves making small incisions in the abdomen.
• Instrument flexibility: NOTES uses a flexible endoscope, while laparoscopic surgery uses rigid instruments. This makes NOTES more challenging for complex procedures.
• Scarring: NOTES is considered scarless, while laparoscopic surgery may result in small scars at the incision sites.
• Immune System Effect: Studies comparing the two surgical techniques reveal that NOTES procedures do not generate as much inflammation in animals as laparoscopic procedures.

The Future of NOTES

The ongoing evolution of NOTES hints at a future of less invasive, potentially scarless surgeries with faster recovery times for many patients. Combining refined techniques, highly specialized technologies, and multiple applications position NOTES as a potential tool for improving surgical outcomes.

Here's a glimpse into how this field is poised for development:

• Enhanced Visualization: Advances in endoscopic cameras and imaging systems aid imaging-guided procedures that facilitate safer navigation through internal structures and improve surgical outcomes.
• Complex Surgeries: As techniques improve and equipment becomes more sophisticated, NOTES could expand into increasingly complex areas. Procedures involving the pancreas, spleen, and some within the chest cavity may become feasible with reduced invasiveness.
• Beyond Surgery: NOTES may increasingly facilitate non-surgical interventions like the targeted delivery of medications or advanced endoscopic diagnostics.
• Robotic-assisted AI-guided surgery: Robotic systems^[14], known for their precision, could be integrated with NOTES, allowing for even greater control and stability during complex procedures. The potential for AI to enhance real-time surgical decision-making and procedural accuracy is immense.

Conclusion

NOTES is a minimally invasive technique that involves accessing the internal organs through natural orifices. It offers many benefits, including faster recovery and better cosmetic outcomes. However, it also has some limitations and challenges that need to be addressed. With advancements in technology, the future of NOTES looks promising, and it may become a more widely used surgical technique.

Show All ▼

Disclaimer