Composition and Health Effects of Common Drinking Water Types

Medically Reviewed by Dr. Sony Sherpa, (MBBS)

While water is universally recognized as essential for life, there remains considerable discussion about the different types of drinking water and their benefits. Should you rely on tap water, switch to filtered water, or choose mineral or alkaline water? With so many different options and conflicting claims, it is easy to feel uncertain. Some people worry about contaminants, while others are drawn to marketing promises of “extra hydration” or “detox benefits.”

The importance of safe drinking water cannot be overstated. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), contaminated water contributes to more than 500,000 diarrheal deaths worldwide annually. At least 1.7 billion people consume water that may be contaminated with feces, creating major public health risks. At the same time, in regions where treated water is widely available, the debate often shifts toward which water type provides the “purest” or “healthiest” option.

Water does more than quench thirst; it regulates body temperature, supports digestion, cushions joints, removes waste, and transports nutrients. Even slight dehydration can affect mood, focus, and energy levels. But beyond the basic need for hydration, the composition of drinking water, its minerals, pH, potential contaminants, and even taste, plays an important role in health and perception. For example, some types of water contain naturally occurring calcium and magnesium that support bone and heart health, while others, such as distilled water, are completely stripped of minerals.

Understanding how different water types are sourced, processed, and marketed can help cut through the confusion and empower consumers to make informed decisions for their health and lifestyle.

The Major Types of Drinking Water

Tap Water

Tap water is the most widely consumed drinking water across the globe, delivered directly into homes via municipal water systems. It typically undergoes several stages of treatment, including sediment filtration, chemical disinfection with chlorine or chloramine, and routine safety testing. In many developed nations, it is regulated to meet strict quality standards set by agencies such as the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the United States or the European Union’s Drinking Water Directive.

However, tap water composition can vary dramatically. The source (river, lake, or underground aquifer), the age of the distribution system, and local environmental factors all influence its quality and the risk of contamination. Despite these concerns, tap water remains one of the most affordable, accessible, and environmentally sustainable hydration options.

Filtered Water

Filtered water usually refers to tap water that has passed through an additional filtration system, such as activated carbon filters, reverse osmosis (RO), or multi-stage purifiers. Activated carbon filters are effective in removing chlorine, sediment, and some volatile organic compounds, improving taste and odor. Reverse osmosis systems go further, removing heavy metals, fluoride, nitrates, and many other contaminants.

Filtration can make water more pleasant to drink and provide reassurance to those concerned about municipal water contaminants. However, some systems, especially RO, also strip away beneficial minerals. This can be addressed by “remineralization filters” that add calcium and magnesium back into the water. However, the main drawback of filtered water is its cost, both in terms of the upfront investment in a system and ongoing maintenance.

Distilled Water

Produced through distillation, this type of water is made by boiling water into vapor and condensing it back to liquid, leaving behind dissolved minerals and contaminants. This makes it one of the purest forms of water available. It is commonly used in laboratories, medical equipment, such as CPAP machines, and industrial processes where mineral deposits must be avoided.

For drinking, distilled water is safe but not necessarily ideal. Since it contains no minerals, it has a flat taste and offers no nutritional benefit.

Mineral Water

Mineral water is sourced from underground reservoirs naturally enriched with minerals such as calcium, magnesium, potassium, and bicarbonates. To qualify as mineral water in the European Union, the water must come directly from a protected underground source and be bottled at the site without additional chemical treatment.

These minerals are what give mineral water its distinctive crisp taste and potential health benefits. Calcium and magnesium support bone strength and heart function, while bicarbonates may help with acid reflux. Mineral water is also often marketed as a premium, “natural” product, which contributes to its higher cost.

Spring Water

Spring water comes from natural springs where underground water emerges to the surface. It is often perceived as pure and fresh, and depending on regulations, may undergo minimal treatment before bottling. Like mineral water, its composition depends on the geology of the source, but it generally contains moderate levels of minerals.

Because it is often less processed, spring water’s quality can be inconsistent. While marketed as natural and pure, it may be vulnerable to contamination if the source is not properly protected. Still, many consumers prefer it for its clean, refreshing taste.

Alkaline Water

Alkaline water refers to water with a higher-than-neutral pH, typically between 8 and 9. It can occur naturally if the source passes through rocks rich in alkaline minerals, but most commercial alkaline water is artificially ionized. Marketers claim it neutralizes acid in the body, slows aging, improves hydration, and even prevents diseases like cancer.

Scientific evidence for these claims remains weak. While alkaline water may temporarily alter the pH of urine or stomach contents, the body tightly regulates blood pH regardless of what we drink. Some research indicates possible benefits for acid reflux or blood viscosity, though the evidence remains limited and does not strongly support the higher cost of alkaline water.

Other Types of Water

• Well Water: Common in rural areas, well water is sourced directly from underground aquifers. Its safety depends heavily on regular testing.
• Purified Water: Refers broadly to any water purified by mechanical filtration or processing to remove impurities, including varieties like distilled and reverse osmosis water.
• Sparkling Water: Carbonated naturally or artificially, sparkling water provides hydration with a fizzy twist. It may contain minerals but can also be slightly acidic, potentially impacting dental enamel.
• Flavored or Infused Water: Enhanced with natural or artificial flavors, sometimes sweetened. While it may encourage people to drink more water, added sugars or additives may offset the benefits.

Health Benefits and Claims

All types of water serve the same basic purpose - hydration. Scientific evidence confirms that plain tap water hydrates just as effectively as mineral, alkaline, or filtered water. However, differences in composition can have subtle effects on health.

• Mineral Water: Provides calcium and magnesium, which play a role in maintaining bone strength and cardiovascular function, offering potential benefits when these minerals are lacking in the diet.
• Alkaline Water: Some small studies suggest it may reduce symptoms of acid reflux and improve post-exercise recovery, but claims of anti-aging, detoxification, and cancer prevention are not supported by strong scientific evidence.
• Filtered Water: Benefits mostly come from improved taste and reduced exposure to chlorine, lead, or other contaminants.
• Distilled Water: Provides no additional health benefits beyond hydration.

Consumer choices are often guided by marketing narratives. Phrases like “pure,” “detoxifying,” or “energizing” can mislead buyers into thinking certain types of water are superior. In reality, unless your local water supply is unsafe, the health differences between water types are minimal.

Potential Health Risks

• Plastic Leaching from Bottled Water: Studies show bottled water often contains microplastics, likely from packaging and bottling processes. Chemicals like bisphenol A (BPA) can also leach from certain plastics, raising concerns about hormonal disruption and long-term health effects.
• Overconsumption of Distilled Water: Drinking only demineralized water may, over time, dilute essential minerals in the body and affect electrolyte balance. While occasional consumption is harmless, exclusive reliance is discouraged.
• Tap Water Contaminants: While regulated, municipal water systems may still face contamination issues, especially in older infrastructure. Lead, nitrates, and pharmaceutical residues are key concerns.
• Well Water Risks: Without regular testing, well water may contain harmful levels of arsenic, nitrates, or bacteria, posing significant health risks.
• Flavored Waters: While convenient, flavored waters containing added sugars may increase the risk of weight gain, insulin resistance, and dental problems.

Conclusion

When it comes to drinking water, safety and hydration matter most. The differences between various water types lie in taste, mineral content, cost, and environmental impact.

For most people, well-regulated tap water is the most practical and eco-friendly choice. If taste or contaminants are a concern, home filtration systems can add an extra layer of protection. Mineral water can provide supplemental minerals, but it is not necessary if you already consume a balanced diet. Alkaline water and flavored waters may be appealing, but should be approached with caution, given the lack of strong scientific support for their claims.

Check your local water quality reports, test your home water if needed, and choose an option that balances safety, sustainability, and personal preference.

To search for the best doctors and healthcare providers worldwide, please use the Mya Care search engine.

Dr. Sony Sherpa completed her MBBS at Guangzhou Medical University, China. She is a resident doctor, researcher, and medical writer who believes in the importance of accessible, quality healthcare for everyone. Her work in the healthcare field is focused on improving the well-being of individuals and communities, ensuring they receive the necessary care and support for a healthy and fulfilling life.

References:

Show All ▼

Disclaimer