SHOULD PEOPLE OVER 80 HAVE SPINE SURGERY?

Medically Reviewed by Dr. Sony Sherpa, (MBBS)

Spine surgery, encompassing a range of procedures aimed at alleviating pain and improving function, has seen increasing prevalence among elderly populations. As medical advancements extend lifespans, the question of whether people over 80 should undergo spine surgery has become a significant dilemma. The balance between potential benefits and inherent risks is crucial for this age group, making it imperative to weigh the options carefully.

Understanding Spine Surgery in Older Adults

Spine surgery in older adults can involve various procedures, each with distinct goals and techniques. Common procedures include:

• Decompression Surgery: This aims to relieve pressure on spinal nerves caused by conditions like spinal stenosis. By removing parts of bone or tissue, the surgery can alleviate pain and improve mobility.
• Fusion Surgery: In this procedure, two or more vertebrae are fused together to eliminate painful motion between them. It is often recommended for conditions such as degenerative disc disease or severe spinal instability.
• Minimally Invasive Techniques: These procedures use smaller incisions and specialized instruments, reducing recovery time and minimizing the risks associated with traditional open surgeries. Endoscopic discectomy and percutaneous vertebroplasty are gaining traction as minimally invasive procedures that prioritize patient well-being.

Despite advancements in surgical techniques, the decision to operate on patients over 80 demands a thorough evaluation of overall health, symptom impact, and the potential for improved well-being.

Factors to Consider

Patient’s Health Status

• Pre-existing Medical Conditions: Conditions such as heart disease, diabetes, and other chronic illnesses can significantly impact the patient's ability to withstand surgery and recover post-operatively. Studies indicate that elderly patients with fewer comorbidities tend to have better outcomes post-surgery.
• Cognitive Function and Ability to Tolerate Surgery: Cognitive impairment can affect the patient's ability to understand the procedure, adhere to post-operative care, and participate in rehabilitation. Cognitive function assessment is a vital part of surgical eligibility determination.
• Functional Limitations Caused by Spinal Condition: The severity of pain and mobility issues caused by the spinal condition can influence the decision. If the spinal condition severely limits the patient's daily activities and quality of life, surgery might be more strongly considered. Research shows that patients who experience significant pre-operative disability can achieve marked improvements post-surgery.
• Life Expectancy and Desired Quality of Life: Evaluating the patient’s life expectancy and their goals for quality of life is essential. Surgery may be justified if it can significantly enhance their remaining years in terms of reduced pain and increased independence.

Type of Spine Surgery

• Minimally Invasive vs. Open Surgery: Minimally invasive surgeries typically offer shorter recovery times and fewer complications compared to traditional open surgeries. However, not all spinal conditions can be addressed with minimally invasive techniques. Studies have found that minimally invasive procedures are particularly beneficial for elderly patients, reducing hospital stays and recovery times.
• Complexity of the Procedure and Potential Risks: The complexity of the proposed surgery and the associated risks must be thoroughly discussed. More complex procedures carry higher risks and may necessitate longer recovery periods.
• Expected Recovery Time and Rehabilitation Needs: Recovery time and the extent of rehabilitation required post-surgery are critical factors. The patient’s willingness and ability to commit to rehabilitation play a significant role in the overall success of the surgery.

Benefits vs. Risks

Potential Benefits of Spine Surgery for Patients Over 80

• Improved Quality of Life:
  • Reduced Pain and Improved Mobility: A successful spine surgery can substantially improve a patient's quality of life by reducing pain and increasing mobility.
  • Increased Independence and Ability to Perform Daily Activities: Successful surgery can restore a level of independence, enabling patients to manage daily tasks more effectively. Research indicates that many elderly patients report substantial improvements in pain relief and functional status post-surgery.
  • Enhanced Participation in Social Life: Reduced pain and increased mobility can also enhance social interactions and overall mental health.
• Preserving Functionality:
  • Preventing Further Degeneration and Disability: Surgery can halt the progression of spinal degeneration, preventing further disability. Early intervention is crucial in managing spinal conditions, as research shows it can prevent the progression of spinal disorders.
  • Maintaining Long-term Physical Health and Well-Being: Improved spinal health can contribute to the patient's overall physical well-being, helping them maintain a healthier lifestyle.

Potential Risks of Spine Surgery for Patients Over 80

• Complications: Surgery carries risks of complications such as infection, blood clots, and issues related to anesthesia. Older adults are particularly susceptible to these risks, which can lead to prolonged recovery or additional medical interventions. Studies emphasize that while the overall mortality risk is low, the potential for post-operative complications remains a significant concern.
• Cognitive Decline or Delirium Post-surgery: Elderly patients are at higher risk for cognitive decline or delirium following surgery, which can complicate recovery and rehabilitation.

The decision to undergo spine surgery for people over 80 is complex and must be personalized, considering the patient's health status, type of surgery, and potential benefits versus risks.

Decision-Making Process

Importance of Patient Participation

The decision to undergo spine surgery, particularly for those over 80, should be a collaborative effort involving the patient, their family, and medical professionals. Shared decision-making ensures that the patient's preferences, values, and goals are central to the treatment plan. This approach not only respects the patient's autonomy but also helps them feel more informed and empowered about their healthcare choices.

Factors to Consider

Several key factors must be evaluated before deciding on spine surgery for elderly individuals. These include Medical History, Current Health Status, Severity of the Spinal Condition and Life Expectancy. :

Role of Pre-Operative Assessments

Pre-operative assessments are vital in determining the suitability of elderly patients for spine surgery. These evaluations include:

• Diagnostic Imaging: MRI, CT and X-ray imaging provide detailed views of the spine to accurately pinpoint the source of the problem.
• Cardiopulmonary Evaluation: Assessing heart and lung function ensures that the patient can tolerate anesthesia and the physical stress of surgery.
• Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment: This includes evaluating cognitive function, nutritional status, and overall physical health to ensure that the patient is a good candidate for surgery.
• Functional Assessments: Tests to measure the patient's mobility, balance, and overall physical capabilities can help predict their ability to recover and participate in post-operative rehabilitation.

What Should the Patient Know Before Going Forward with the Surgery?

Elderly patients considering spine surgery should thoroughly understand the surgical process, potential outcomes, and recovery steps. Here are some key points that should be explained to help them make an informed decision.

Pre-Surgery Information

• Purpose of the Surgery: Understanding the specific goals of the surgery-whether it is to relieve pain, improve mobility, or stabilize the spine-is essential. This helps set realistic expectations about the potential benefits.
• Procedure Details: Patients should be aware of the type of surgery recommended (e.g., decompression, fusion, or minimally invasive techniques), the steps involved, and the expected duration of the surgery.
• Pre-Operative Preparations: Instructions on preparing for surgery, such as fasting, medication adjustments, and any necessary pre-surgery tests, should be clearly communicated.
• Risks and Complications: While surgery carries inherent risks at any age, older patients are more susceptible to complications such as infection, blood clots, anesthesia-related issues, and prolonged recovery.

Recovery and Rehabilitation

• Pain Relief and Improved Mobility: Your healthcare team can guide you to put together a pain management plan that may include medication, physical therapy, and other strategies. Successful surgery can lead to significant pain reduction and improved mobility. Patients may experience a noticeable improvement in their ability to perform daily activities.
• Recovery Timeline: Post-surgery recovery times can vary, but patients should expect a gradual improvement over weeks to months. Minimally invasive procedures typically offer quicker recovery times compared to traditional open surgeries.
• Rehabilitation and Physical Therapy: Physical therapy plays a vital role in the rehabilitation process. This helps restore strength, flexibility, and function. Patients should be prepared for regular therapy sessions and exercises at home.

Complications

• Post-Operative Complications: Post-surgical infections are a risk, especially in elderly patients. Carefully monitor the surgical site for signs of infection and follow your doctor's post-operative care instructions closely to minimize the risk of complications. Other complications might include blood clots, or adverse reactions to anesthesia. These issues may require additional medical interventions and could prolong the recovery period.
• Delayed Recovery and Rehabilitation Challenges: Recovery may take longer than expected, and some patients might face challenges in rehabilitation. This can include difficulty in regaining strength and mobility, which may necessitate extended physical therapy or the use of assistive devices.
• Persistent Pain or Functional Limitations: In some cases, the surgery may not fully alleviate pain or improve function as anticipated. Persistent or worsening pain should be reported to your doctor. Patients should be aware of the possibility of needing ongoing pain management or additional surgery to resolve problems.
• Cognitive Decline or Delirium: Elderly patients are at higher risk for post-operative cognitive issues, such as delirium or a decline in cognitive function. Awareness and early intervention are important to manage these potential complications.

How to Prepare for Spine Surgery if You Are Over 80

Here are some steps to ensure you are in the best possible condition for the procedure:

• Stop Smoking: Smoking can reduce blood flow and slow down the healing process. Quitting smoking well before the surgery can significantly improve your recovery outcomes.
• Lose Weight: Losing weight can significantly alleviate pressure on the spine and speed up recovery. Consult your healthcare provider for a weight loss plan tailored to your needs.
• Stay Physically Active: Engaging in physical activity, as advised by your doctor, can strengthen your muscles and improve your overall health. Walking and low-impact exercises can be particularly beneficial as per your physical capacity.
• Eat Healthy: To optimize your body's healing process, consume a balanced diet rich in vitamins, minerals, and protein. Incorporate plenty of fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains into your meals.

Latest Advancements in Spine Surgery for Elderly Patients

• Minimally Invasive Techniques: Endoscopic discectomy and percutaneous vertebroplasty are newer minimally invasive techniques particularly beneficial for elderly patients.
• Enhanced Pain Management Protocols: Modern pain management strategies aim to minimize post-operative discomfort. This includes the implementation of multimodal pain management plans, combining various pain relief methods for optimal outcomes.
• Robotic-Assisted Surgery: Robotic-assisted surgery offers enhanced precision, leading to improved outcomes and potentially reduced operative times.

These advancements can reduce the risk of complications and improve recovery rates.

Alternatives to Spine Surgery for Elderly Patients

For elderly patients who may not be ideal candidates for spine surgery due to health concerns or personal preferences, several alternative treatments can help manage symptoms and improve quality of life.

Conservative Management

• Physical Therapy: Dedicated physical therapy programs can significantly improve muscular strength, flexibility, and pain relief. Engaging in a structured physical therapy program can significantly improve strength, flexibility, and pain management. Physical therapists can design personalized exercise routines that target specific areas of weakness and discomfort, helping patients maintain mobility and function.
• Medication: Medications such as NSAIDs, acetaminophen, and muscle relaxants can effectively manage chronic pain and inflammation associated with spinal conditions. Pain relief medications, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), acetaminophen, and muscle relaxants, can be effective in managing chronic pain and inflammation associated with spinal conditions. In some cases, stronger medications, such as like opioids may be prescribed for short-term use under careful medical supervision.
• Lifestyle Modifications: Implementing changes in daily habits can have a profound impact on spinal health. This includes weight management to reduce stress on the spine, posture correction to prevent further injury, and incorporating regular low-impact exercise like walking or swimming into daily routines.

Non-surgical Interventions

• Epidural Steroid Injections: These injections deliver corticosteroids directly into the epidural space around the spinal nerves, providing targeted pain relief and reducing inflammation. This treatment is especially helpful for patients with herniated discs or spinal stenosis, offering significant pain relief without surgical intervention. This can be particularly beneficial for conditions like herniated discs or spinal stenosis, offering relief without the need for surgery.
• Spinal Bracing: Wearing a spinal brace can provide support and stability to the affected area of the spine. Braces can help reduce pain, improve posture, and prevent further injury, making daily activities more manageable for elderly patients.
• Assistive Devices: Assistive devices such as walkers and canes provide essential support, improving both mobility and quality of life. The use of assistive devices such as walkers or canes can enhance mobility and independence. These tools help distribute weight more evenly and reduce the strain on the spine, allowing patients to move with greater ease and confidence.

To search for the best Orthopedics Healthcare Providers in Croatia, Germany, India, Malaysia, Singapore, Spain, Thailand, Turkey, the UAE, UK and the USA, please use the Mya Care search engine.

References:

• Balabaud, L., et al. "Lumbar spine surgery in patients 80 years of age or older: morbidity and mortality." European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology 25 (2015): 205-212.
• Epstein, Nancy E. "Spine surgery in geriatric patients: Sometimes unnecessary, too much, or too little." Surgical neurology international 2 (2011).
• Liang, H., Lu, S., Jiang, D., & Fei, Q. (2020). Clinical outcomes of lumbar spinal surgery in patients 80 years or older with lumbar stenosis or spondylolisthesis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. European Spine Journal, 29, 2129-2142.
• Bouloussa, Houssam, et al. "Is it safe to perform lumbar spine surgery on patients over eighty five?." International Orthopaedics 41 (2017): 2091-2096.
• Kobayashi, Kazuyoshi, et al. "Complications associated with spine surgery in patients aged 80 years or older: Japan Association of Spine Surgeons with Ambition (JASA) multicenter study." Global spine journal 7.7 (2017): 636-641.
• Kweh, Barry, et al. "Spinal surgery in patients aged 80 years and older: risk stratification using the modified frailty index." Global Spine Journal 11.4 (2021): 525-532.
• Nanjo, Yoshiro, et al. "Clinical features and surgical outcomes of lumbar spinal stenosis in patients aged 80 years or older: a multi-center retrospective study." Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery 133 (2013): 1243-1248.
• Cloyd, Jordan M., Frank L. Acosta Jr, and Christopher P. Ames. "Complications and outcomes of lumbar spine surgery in elderly people: a review of the literature." Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 56.7 (2008): 1318-1327.
• Fehlings, Michael G., et al. "Future advances in spine surgery: the AOSpine North America perspective." Neurosurgery 80.3S (2017): S1-S8.
• Choi, Jun-Young, et al. "Recent updates on minimally invasive spine surgery: techniques, technologies, and indications." Asian spine journal 16.6 (2022): 1013.
• Bridwell, Keith H., et al. "What's new in spine surgery." JBJS 93.16 (2011): 1560-1566.

Disclaimer