XENOTRANSPLANTATION - COULD PIG LIVERS END THE TRANSPLANT WAITLIST?

Medically Reviewed by Dr. Sony Sherpa (MBBS) - September 02, 2024

Xenotransplantation is a medical procedure in which organs are transplanted from animals to humans. This method has gained attention as a probable answer to the critical shortage of human donor organs for transplantation.

The idea of xenotransplantation is not new, but its importance has increased due to the growing gap between the demand for donor organs and their limited supply. This approach could revolutionize how we address organ failure and save countless lives, especially for patients on lengthy organ transplant waiting lists.

A recent pig liver xenotransplant yielded promising results, taking us closer to doing away with organ waiting lists.^[1] This blog looks at the latest breakthrough transplant, the science behind xenotransplantation, its pros and cons, and what we can expect from the future of xenotransplantation.

A Brief History of Xenotransplants

Xenotransplantation has a long history marked by numerous attempts and milestones. Since the early 20th century, it has seen successes and setbacks, contributing to our current understanding and approach to interspecies organ transplants.

An early attempt in 1964 involved the transplantation of a chimpanzee kidney to a human, providing crucial insights despite the recipient's survival for only nine months post-transplant. Human recipients also received donor organs from pigs, cows, and goats with minimal success.^[2]

Moving towards the 21st century, scientists realized that genetic compatibility and immune involvement were the main hurdles to xenotransplantation.

Research intensified on using pigs as organ donors, driven by their physiological compatibility with humans and easier breeding conditions. In the last decade, several breakthroughs in pig-to-human transplantation have shown promise, particularly in the context of kidney and heart transplantation.

These pioneering procedures laid the groundwork for the current state of xenotransplantation, teaching invaluable lessons about immune rejection and the complexities of cross-species organ compatibility.

Breaking News: First Successful Pig Liver Xenotransplantation

In a landmark achievement in the field of medicine, surgeons recently performed the first successful procedure using a genetically modified pig liver in a brain-dead human patient. They filtered the patient’s blood for 72 hours after externally connecting the liver to the patient’s body. This breakthrough represents a significant leap forward in xenotransplantation, offering new hope for patients with acute liver failure.^[3]

The pig liver used in this procedure underwent nearly 70 genetic modifications to make it more compatible with the human body.^[4] These modifications reduced the risk of organ rejection, a common challenge in transplants. The liver received prior conditioning to minimize the risk of transmitting animal-borne diseases to the patient, addressing a key concern in xenotransplantation.

With the severe shortage of human livers available for transplant, xenotransplantation could dramatically shorten waiting times, providing a lifesaving alternative for those in critical need. This approach could also reduce the dependency on human donors, alleviating the pressure on the transplant system.

While the procedure's initial success is promising, it also presents challenges that need careful consideration. The long-term outcomes and potential risks, such as immune rejection and the ethical implications of using animal organs for human transplants, remain areas of ongoing research and debate. It is essential to monitor and study these transplants to ensure safety, efficacy, and ethical integrity.

How Does Xenotransplantation Work?

Xenotransplantation involves transplanting cells, tissues, or organs from one species to another, typically from animals to humans.

This process starts with selecting and genetically modifying donor animals, such as pigs, to make their organs more compatible with human bodies. The transplanted organ must then function adequately in the human recipient, a complex challenge given the biological differences between species.

Xenotransplantation vs. Allotransplantation

In contrast to allotransplantation (organs transplanted between humans), xenotransplantation faces additional hurdles. The main difference lies in the immune response. Human bodies are more likely to reject animal organs due to their foreign nature. Allotransplantation, while still carrying rejection risks, generally deals with a lesser degree of immune system activation.

Immune Response and Rejection

The human immune system naturally fights off foreign entities, making organ rejection the biggest challenge in xenotransplantation. To address this, scientists genetically modify animal organs to minimize rejection risks. Despite these modifications, patients require lifelong immunosuppressive medications to stop their immune systems from destroying the transplanted organ.

How do Human and Pig Organs Compare?

Pigs are considered ideal donor candidates for xenotransplantation due to several physiological similarities to humans. Some key similarities include^[5]:

1. Organ Size and Anatomy: Pigs have organs comparable in size and structure to human organs, making them suitable for transplantation into human recipients.
2. Physiological Functions: The functional aspects of pig organs, such as kidneys and hearts, are sufficiently similar to their human counterparts, allowing them to perform effectively in the human body.
3. Growth Rate and Maturity: Pigs have a rapid growth rate and reach maturity quickly, which is beneficial for harvesting organs promptly.
4. Genetics: Tissues from pigs are almost entirely genetically compatible with humans.

However, notable differences in tissue structure, organ function, and lifespan still pose challenges for successful transplantation.

Weighing Xenotransplantation Pros and Cons

Xenotransplantation could significantly alleviate the shortage of human organs for transplantation. Other potential benefits include:

• Reduced Waiting Times: It could significantly decrease the waiting times for patients needing organ transplants, thereby reducing mortality rates among those on transplant waiting lists.
• Cheaper Organ Transplants: The cost of readily transplantable genetically modified animal organs is considerably less than waiting months for a freshly donated human organ.
• Potential for Customization: Genetic modification of animal organs may allow for customized organs tailored to the recipient's needs, potentially reducing the chances of rejection.
• Advancement in Medical Research: Xenotransplantation drives forward scientific research and understanding in genetics, immunology, and transplantation medicine.
• Benefit for Rare Blood Types: It could particularly benefit patients with rare blood types or those who are hard to match with human donors.

The risks of xenotransplantation are not insignificant. There is currently no way to ensure animal organs' long-term viability and functionality in human bodies.

Xenotransplants may pose the following disadvantages:

• Long-Term Health Impact: The long-term effects of living with an animal organ on health are unknown and could pose unforeseen complications.
• Psychological Impact: Receiving an animal organ might have psychological impacts on patients, including issues of acceptance and mental health considerations.
• Risk of Disease Transmission (Zoonosis)^[6]: There is a risk of transmitting animal viruses and diseases to humans, which could have unknown and potentially severe public health implications.

Further scientific refinements can help lessen these drawbacks in the future.

Ethical Considerations: There are also some ethical concerns to consider. These include concerns about animal welfare, the moral implications of using animals for human benefit, and the potential long-term effects on the human genome.^[7]

The Future Horizon: Ongoing Research and Potential Impact

Xenotransplantation is evolving rapidly, with research focused on better genetic modifications and advanced immunosuppression to enhance compatibility and reduce rejection risks. Research is expanding into transplanting other organs like hearts, lungs, and tissues for diabetes treatment, offering unique challenges and opportunities.

The success of xenotransplantation could revolutionize organ availability, significantly reducing waiting times and improving patient outcomes.

Conclusion

In conclusion, xenotransplantation stands at the forefront of medical innovation, offering hope amid organ shortages. While it poses ethical, biological, and technical challenges, ongoing research and recent successes suggest a promising future. As this field evolves, it could significantly alter the landscape of organ transplantation, enhancing life-saving opportunities for patients worldwide. However, continuous research, ethical deliberation, and careful consideration of risks are essential as we step into this new era of medical science.

To search for Transplant healthcare providers worldwide, please use the Mya Care search engine 

To search for the best doctors and healthcare providers worldwide, please use the Mya Care search engine.

Sources:

Disclaimer