WHAT IS DIGITAL DEMENTIA? THE HEALTH IMPACT OF SCREEN TIME

Medically Reviewed by Dr. Rosmy Barrios

Technology has become a central part of our daily lives in the digital era. The increased reliance we have on technology is also changing how we use our brains. From smartphones to laptops, we are constantly connected to screens, which has raised concerns about the impact of technology on cognition. 

One of the most prevalent issues is digital dementia, a term coined by neuroscientist Dr. Manfred Spitzer. While not a recognized medical condition, digital dementia is a theory with growing scientific momentum as researchers explore the effects that the digital world imparts on memory and overall cognition.

This article will explore digital dementia, its symptoms, and the latest research on its impact on our health. 

What is Digital Dementia?

Digital dementia is a theory proposed by Dr. Manfred Spitzer, a German neuroscientist who suggests excessive technology use can lead to a global decline in cognitive abilities, similar to dementia. Dementia is a neurological condition with a wide variety of causes that lead to impaired mental functions, including memory recall, attention span, and reasoning ability.

The theory is based on the idea that our brains constantly adapt to the environment, and the overuse of technology can lead to a trade-off between using certain cognitive functions, resulting in dementia.

Spitzer's theory focuses on these key points:

• Reduced Focus and Concentration: According to Spitzer, constant technology use can lead to an inability to maintain deep, sustained focus on tasks.
• Multitasking Overload: He argues that excessive digital multitasking can lead to mental fatigue as the brain struggles to switch rapidly between tasks.
• Information Overload: Spitzer suggests that constant exposure to a barrage of online information can overwhelm our cognitive resources, making it harder to process and retain what is truly important.
• Digital Devices Over Memory Recall: To further support the theory, constant reliance on digital devices for information reduces the requirement for retaining the details and practicing memory recall.

Latest Digital Dementia Research

While the term digital dementia was coined in 2012, the concept has been around for much longer. The scientific community has debated technology's cognitive impact for decades.

Some researchers believe that technology leads to memory atrophy and a decline in cognitive function. Others argue that the brain is plastic and adapts to new technologies, suggesting that the brain is trading one type of intelligence for another.

A 2022 study published in the Journal of Integrative Neuroscience highlights the potential link between excessive screen time and the development of Alzheimer's disease and related dementias (ADRD). In line with the theory of digital dementia, researchers posit that over-reliance on digital devices for memory storage, along with constant distractions and information overload, may weaken essential cognitive functions over time.

The study underscores a growing concern that the habits of the "internet generation" increase their risk for ADRD in adulthood by four to six times. The study's authors emphasize the need for educational campaigns and proactive measures to address this potential public health issue.

Other studies have assessed the impact of digital devices on selective aspects of cognition, as discussed below.

Memory

There is evidence that technology can negatively affect episodic memory, as people rely on digital devices to store information:

• A study conducted at Trinity College Dublin found that people under 30 are less likely to remember their home phone number and family birthdays without checking their mobile phones compared to people over 50. This suggests that technology may be leading to a decline in episodic memory.
• A study by South Korean psychiatrist Yoon Se-Chang found that people rely more on digital devices to search for information than memorize it. This suggests that technology may be improving our ability to search for information but reducing our ability to remember.
• Another study shows that frequent GPS use leads to decreased spatial memory, and people rely less on spatial memory strategies. In other words, GPS technologies cause people to dispense with the need to understand geography and physically navigate new areas.

Social media can also be a tool to store and share memories that may detract from the user's ability to store and recall them.

On the other hand, some studies suggest digital tools can aid certain types of memory, especially when considering learning apps designed to help the user study or learn through a similar format to flash cards.

Attention

Some research indicates that heavy digital media use may be linked to shorter attention spans and difficulty focusing.

• A research study published by Nature Communications suggests that the increasing pace of information consumption and production has led to a decline in attention span. This is evident in the shorter lifespans of trending topics and the rapid shift of collective attention from one subject to another. While this acceleration can lead to a more dynamic and diverse information landscape, it also poses challenges in terms of information overload and fragmented understanding of complex issues.

Other research shows a link between higher levels of ADHD in young children who use digital devices:

• One study revealed a positive link between infants allowed to watch television at 18 months and the development of ADHD at 30 months.
• Another study found that toddlers who spent more than 90 minutes a day on a digital device, such as a tablet, were prone to contracting ADHD symptoms by the age of 3.
• Further findings indicate that toddlers who spent longer looking at screens had higher hyperactivity index scores and levels of hyperactive behavior.

ADHD symptoms are not the only developmental problems that child technology use can cause. Other studies suggest it may lower a child's ability to recall information learned in school, interfering with language skills and social aptitude.

Executive Function

Executive function refers to mental processes for planning, organizing, and problem-solving. There is limited evidence to support Spitzer's theory regarding the impact of technology on higher-order cognitive skills. He suggests that the overuse of technology may negatively impact cognitive abilities, similar to the effects of excessive alcohol consumption.

Research examining how it impacts attention span and memory can extend toward overall executive functioning. Some studies also suggest that screen time promotes impulsivity and lowers the ability to make rational decisions, which pertains to executive cognition. Overuse of digital devices has also been linked with diminished brain connectivity between various regions that culminate in optimal cognition. However, systematic reviews also underscore the need for rigorous research to definitively assess the association between screen time, cognition, and executive functioning, as current evidence remains inconclusive.

Other studies conflict with these findings, revealing that IQ scores across children are rising globally despite diminishing vocabularies and less time spent on reading or building skills of memory recall.

Technological Impact on Physical Factors Affecting Cognition

Spending large amounts of time glued to a digital device is also connected to:

• Lower levels of physical activity
• Sleep disturbances
• Poor posture
• Higher radiation exposure levels

These factors can influence cognition by interfering with the brain's blood supply and regenerative capacity.

Symptoms of Digital Dementia

The symptoms of digital dementia are similar to those of traditional dementia, including memory loss, difficulty concentrating, and impaired cognitive function. However, digital dementia is more prevalent in younger individuals, and the symptoms may manifest differently.

Some common symptoms of digital dementia include:

• Short attention span
• Poor memory, especially when attempting to recall recent events, dates, or new names
• Difficulties with word finding 
• Impaired problem-solving ability
• Lack of empathy
• Poor social skills
• Decreased ability to focus
• Impaired decision-making
• Developmental delays in social, physical, and language skills
• Reduced emotional regulation
• Heightened impulsivity

Other Concerns About Technology

While digital dementia is a significant concern, there are other potential health impacts of excessive screen time. These include:

• Poor posture, lower physical capacity, and musculoskeletal problems
• Eye strain and vision problems
• Sleep disturbances
• Raised odds of obesity and chronic diseases, including cardiovascular disease
• Social isolation and decreased social skills
• Addiction and dependency on technology

Digital Detox vs. Balanced Tech Use

Some researchers and experts, including Dr. Spitzer, emphasize the temporary nature of digital dementia, likening the concept to a reversible condition that largely corrects itself through abstinence. This is where digital detoxing rose to popularity.

As the term suggests, digital detox refers to taking a break from technology to reduce its negative impact on our health. While this may seem like a drastic measure, it can be beneficial for both children and adults. A digital detox can help reduce screen time and allow our brains to rest and recover from the constant stimulation of technology.

A few digital detox benefits include:

• Enhanced Mental Well-being: Taking a break from screens can clear mental fog, reduce anxiety, and improve overall mood by allowing our brains a much-needed reset.
• Improved Focus and Concentration: Removing digital distractions can help us regain the ability to concentrate on single tasks for extended periods, boosting productivity and depth of thought.
• Reconnecting with the Present: Disengaging from devices allows us to be more fully present in the real world, strengthening connections with others and fostering mindfulness.

Digital detoxing can also improve sleep, enhance the quality of our relationships, and allow us to have more time to pursue the things we find enjoyable.

While a full digital detox can be powerful, achieving a sustainable, balanced relationship with technology is crucial in the long run. This involves recognizing technology's benefits (communication, connection, education) while being mindful of its potential drawbacks. It is about intentionally curating our digital experiences and avoiding the trap of constant mindless consumption.

The balanced tech use approach involves setting limits on screen time, taking breaks, and engaging in activities such as exercise, immersing in nature, reading, or spending time with loved ones.

How to Reduce the Risk of Digital Dementia

While the research on digital dementia is still in its early stages, there are steps we can take to reduce the risk of developing this condition. These include:

• Limiting screen time, especially for young children and teens, and in the 1-2 hours before bedtime
• Encouraging physical activity and outdoor play
• Engaging in brain-stimulating activities like games, puzzles, and reading 
• Taking frequent breaks from electronic devices during the day
• Switching notifications off, walking away, or packing digital devices out of sight when taking a break from technology
• Making use of technology-free work breaks
• Practicing mindfulness and being present in the moment
• Using digital devices in ways that are conducive to improving cognition
• Opting for quality content across media that encourages deeper thinking and self-development
• Prioritizing the storing and organizing of information in a clear format on digital devices
• Making an effort to recall more information than what is presented when interacting with a digital device
• Spending time on creative or literary pursuits that involve journaling, reading, writing, and artistic expression
• Creating tech-free zones in your house (especially bedrooms and dining areas) and work environment
• Setting aside the time for social connection in a tech-free environment

Conclusion

Digital dementia is a growing concern in today’s digital age, and the research on its impact on our health is still in its early stages. However, excessive screen time can harm our cognitive abilities, particularly in children and adolescents.

By practicing balanced tech use and taking regular breaks from technology, we can reduce the risk of developing digital dementia and other health issues associated with excessive screen time.

Sources:

Show More ▼

 

Disclaimer